Newcastle United are turning heads yet again in the transfer market — and this time, the spotlight is firmly on Nottingham Forest’s Anthony Elanga. A winger blessed with explosive pace, agility, and direct attacking flair, Elanga has emerged as a primary target for the Magpies’ summer rebuild. But behind the hype, this move is sparking intense debate — is it a masterstroke or a miscalculated swing?
The interest itself isn’t new. Newcastle made a serious move for Elanga last summer, reportedly tabling a bid in the region of £35 million on deadline day. That offer was swiftly rejected by Forest, who had only just brought the Swedish international in from Manchester United for a modest fee. Fast forward a year, and the Tyneside club are back at the table — this time, likely needing to stump up more than £50 million to convince Forest to part with one of their most exciting assets.
That hefty price tag is already causing eyebrows to rise. Elanga is talented, no question. In the 2024/25 Premier League season, he notched up six goals and eleven assists — solid output for a wide player, particularly in a team that spent much of the season fighting relegation. His raw speed and directness make him a constant threat on the counterattack, and at just 23, there’s room for serious growth. But is that potential worth £50 million in today’s tight financial climate?
Newcastle aren’t operating with a blank checkbook anymore. The club has to navigate the increasingly strict Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR), and as we saw last summer, compliance came at the cost of offloading valuable young talents like Elliot Anderson and Yankuba Minteh.
Fans have become acutely aware of how every transfer must now be weighed carefully, not just in terms of talent, but also financial implications.
And that’s where the Elanga deal becomes risky. While he does offer qualities that Newcastle lack — particularly pace and one-on-one ability on the right flank — he’s still relatively unproven at the top level. His time at Manchester United was patchy, with limited game time and inconsistency holding him back. Forest has given him the platform to develop, and he’s undoubtedly stepped up, but he’s yet to deliver at a European level or in high-pressure knockout scenarios.
Tactically, it’s clear why Eddie Howe and the Newcastle recruitment team are interested. The team struggled with injuries and lacked depth in attacking areas throughout the 2024/25 campaign. Elanga’s profile — fast, direct, hardworking, and able to play on either wing — fits well within Howe’s high-intensity, transition-based system. He would likely rotate with or even displace players like Miguel Almirón, offering a different dimension on the flank.
But that brings us to another question: Is right wing really the priority right now?
Newcastle’s real issues have stemmed from defensive vulnerability and lack of depth in midfield. With key players like Sven Botman and Joelinton missing large parts of the season, the team’s form took a dive. While bolstering the attack is important, it arguably isn’t where the biggest investment should go. Splashing £50 million on Elanga may excite fans short-term but could be questioned if deeper squad issues remain unresolved.
Then there’s the player’s own stance. Elanga has handled the transfer speculation with calm professionalism. “There is talk… I focus on what I can control,” he recently told Swedish media. It’s a textbook response — respectful but distant. He’s not pushing for the move, nor is he dismissing it. That might be refreshing compared to the usual transfer drama, but it also signals that Elanga is in no rush to leave Forest, a club that’s backed him and helped him grow.
Forest, too, have no urgency to sell. The winger is under a long-term contract, and with their Premier League status secure, they hold all the leverage. Unless Newcastle come in with an irresistible offer, this saga could drag on — or end just like it did last year, with nothing but tabloid headlines and “what ifs.”
This potential transfer, therefore, sits at the crossroads of ambition and pragmatism. Newcastle’s intent to push forward is admirable — the club has shaken off its reputation as a mid-table outfit and now operates with Champions League ambitions. But ambition must be paired with wisdom. With the summer window open and Financial Fair Play looming large, every move needs to be part of a bigger strategy.
If Newcastle do secure Elanga, it could work out brilliantly. Under Howe’s guidance, he could evolve into one of the league’s most dynamic wide men, especially if he adds more end product to his game. But if he struggles to adapt, or if other areas of the squad suffer from a lack of investment due to this deal, fans and analysts alike will be quick to ask whether this was a flashy move that lacked foresight.
The Premier League has no room for mistakes at the top. The competition is fierce, the margins are fine, and every big-money transfer is a roll of the dice. Newcastle are on the cusp of something special — but this Elanga pursuit must be more than just a headline-grabbing gesture.
Only time will tell if this gamble pays off — or if it becomes yet another cautionary tale in the high-stakes game of modern football transfers.
Leave a Reply